Arts and culture
Byzantine history
What is each chatbot's top 10?
Filled dot: the name is in a page the answer cited. Ring: it is not.
- 1AKAnthony Kaldellis
- 2JHJohn Haldon
- 3
Judith Herrin - 4
Peter Frankopan
- 5DADimiter Angelov
- 6WTWarren Treadgold
- 7
Paul Magdalino - 8CHCatherine Holmes
- 9
Leonora Neville - 10PSPeter Sarris
- 1GOGeorge Ostrogorsky
- 2
Angeliki E. Laiou - 3
Alexander Kazhdan - 4CMCyril Mango
- 5DODimitri Obolensky
- 6
Hélène Ahrweiler - 7IŠIhor Ševčenko
- 8
Gilbert Dagron - 9SRSteven Runciman
- 10JHJohn Haldon
- 1GOGeorge Ostrogorsky
- 2
Alexander Vasiliev - 3SRSteven Runciman
- 4DODimitri Obolensky
- 5CMCyril Mango
- 6
Averil Cameron - 7
Judith Herrin - 8JHJohn Haldon
- 9AKAnthony Kaldellis
- 10WTWarren Treadgold
- 1AKAnthony Kaldellis
- 2JHJohn Haldon
- 3
Averil Cameron - 4
Judith Herrin - 5
Paul Magdalino - 6
Peter Brown
- 7
Leonora Neville - 8JHJames Howard-Johnston
- 9GOGeorge Ostrogorsky
- 10DADimiter Angelov
- 1GOGeorge Ostrogorsky
- 2SRSteven Runciman
- 3CMCyril Mango
- 4
Alexander Kazhdan - 5DODimitri Obolensky
- 6JHJohn Haldon
- 7AKAnthony Kaldellis
- 8
Judith Herrin - 9WTWarren Treadgold
- 10
Averil Cameron
- 1
Judith Herrin - 2
Averil Cameron - 3
Peter Brown
- 4CMCyril Mango
- 5
Alexander Kazhdan - 6JHJohn Haldon
- 7WTWarren Treadgold
- 8AKAnthony Kaldellis
- 9
Angeliki E. Laiou - 10GOGeorge Ostrogorsky
Who does each model name, and at what rank?
Rank each list gave a name; blank means the list left it out.
| GPT-5 | Claude | Gemini | Grok | Muse | ChatGPT app | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| George Ostrogorsky | #1 | #1 | #9 | #1 | #10 | |
| John Haldon | #10 | #8 | #2 | #6 | #6 | #2 |
| Cyril Mango | #4 | #5 | #3 | #4 | ||
| Judith Herrin | #7 | #4 | #8 | #1 | #3 | |
| Averil Cameron | #6 | #3 | #10 | #2 | ||
| Anthony Kaldellis | #9 | #1 | #7 | #8 | #1 | |
| Alexander Kazhdan | #3 | #4 | #5 | |||
| Dimitri Obolensky | #5 | #4 | #5 | |||
| Steven Runciman | #9 | #3 | #2 | |||
| Warren Treadgold | #10 | #9 | #7 | #6 | ||
| Peter Brown | #6 | #3 | ||||
| Angeliki E. Laiou | #2 | #9 | ||||
| Alexander Vasiliev | #2 | |||||
| Paul Magdalino | #5 | #7 | ||||
| Hélène Ahrweiler | #6 | |||||
| Ihor Ševčenko | #7 | |||||
| Leonora Neville | #7 | #9 | ||||
| Gilbert Dagron | #8 | |||||
| James Howard-Johnston | #8 | |||||
| Dimiter Angelov | #10 | #5 |
Who does every model name?
On all five API lists for this field.
Who does only one model name?
On one API list for this field and no other.
How many names do two models share?
Names in common between two API top-10 lists in this field.
| GPT-5 | Claude | Gemini | Grok | Muse | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GPT-5 | 5 | 2 | 6 | 5 | |
| Claude Sonnet 5 | 5 | 5 | 9 | 7 | |
| Gemini 3.5 Flash | 2 | 5 | 5 | 6 | |
| Grok 4.5 | 6 | 9 | 5 | 8 | |
| Muse Spark 1.2 | 5 | 7 | 6 | 8 |
How many names do the API and the web app share?
Names in common between a model's API top-10 list and its web app's, in this field.
| GPT-5 | Claude | Gemini | Grok | Muse | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| API vs web app | 1 | – | – | – | – |
Do the cited pages back each list?
Each list in this field, by what its cited pages contain.
- GPT-5 APINo sources cited
- Claude Sonnet 5 APIMost names in cited pages
- Gemini 3.5 Flash APISome names in cited pages
- Grok 4.5 APIMost names in cited pages
- Muse Spark 1.2 APISome names in cited pages
- ChatGPT Web appNo sources cited
How many listed names appear in the cited pages?
Share of each list found in a page it cited. Blank: no pages cited.
Which websites do chatbots cite here?
Cited pages per website, all lists in this field.
What did each chatbot answer?
GPT-5API0 sources
How we read this list: The answer gives a main list of 10, then a second list of more names. Kept the main list.
- No sources cited.
ChatGPTWeb app0 sources
How we read this list: Read from the page text.
- No sources cited.
Claude Sonnet 5API6 sources
- 1Byzantine Tradition - Modern Scholarshipbyzantinetradition.org, 6 of 10 names
- 2Alexander Vasiliev (historian) - Wikipediaen.wikipedia.org, 1 of 10 names
- 3John Haldon — The Bosphorus Review Of Booksbosphorusreview.com, 4 of 10 names
- 4Byzantine studies - Wikipediaen.wikipedia.org, 6 of 10 names
- 5The Middle Byzantine Historians | Springer Nature Linklink.springer.com, 2 of 10 names
- 6Oxford Centre for Byzantine Research | Faculty of Historyhistory.ox.ac.uk, 3 of 10 names
Gemini 3.5 FlashAPI5 sources
- 1Redditreddit.com, page unreadable
- 2eileenstephenson.comeileenstephenson.com, page unreadable
- 3expertisefinder.comnetwork.expertisefinder.com, 1 of 10 names
- 4wikipedia.orgen.wikipedia.org, 2 of 10 names
- 5harvard.eduangelov.scholars.harvard.edu, page unreadable
Grok 4.5API11 sources
- 11byzantinetradition.org, 6 of 10 names
- 22en.wikipedia.org, 1 of 10 names
- 33bookdna.com, page unreadable
- 44en.wikipedia.org, 1 of 10 names
- 55archive.org, 2 of 10 names
- 66dof.princeton.edu, page unreadable
- 77empressofbyzantium.substack.com, 5 of 10 names
- 88en.wikipedia.org, 1 of 10 names
- 99fivebooks.com, 3 of 10 names
- 1010link.springer.com, 2 of 10 names
- 1111hist.cam.ac.uk, 1 of 10 names
Muse Spark 1.2API3 sources
How we read this list: Slot 10 is 'Foundational Masters', naming Ostrogorsky first; kept him.
- 1Peter Brown (historian) - Wikipediaen.wikipedia.org, 1 of 10 names
- 2Social History of Byzantiumagendabookshop.com, 2 of 10 names
- 3# Dimiter Angelovhistory.fas.harvard.edu, page unreadable